Cushioning is what makes the shoes comfortable, soft, bouncy. Some cushioning units help you feel nice and pampered on those slow recovery days. Others encourage you to speed up, feeling like small trampolines under your feet.
With our independent shoe lab and wear tests, we have reviewed over 100 cushioned running shoes to pick out the cream of the crop.
You can find an all-around workhorse for daily runs, a springy race shoe, or a trail crusher, among others. See our top choices from five different categories below.
And if you’d like to learn more expert tips on finding the best cushioned running shoe for you, scroll down to the guide under the shoe descriptions.
Reinventing the Hoka Signature, the Mach 4 lets go of that cottony-soft feel in favor of a more stable, lively ride. And we couldn’t agree more.
Over 1500+ shoes in our database, the Mach 4 comes on top after acing our tests. After 50 miles in, we can say it’s a standout in providing all-day support and comfort - even more so than its Clifton sibling.
For a shoe with all that foam, the Mach 4 is incredibly light! In our scales, it weighs in at 7.85 oz, while the average shoes sit at 9.4 oz (in our lab testing result). This also reflects on the run, we didn’t feel the shoe dragging the foot. It’s so light, we even forgot it’s there.
What makes the Mach an even greater shoe is that it has a locked-in fit. It’s not too stretchy, creating that secure wrap around the contours of the foot.
It’s hard to decide where it sits in our rotation. But if there’s one thing we’re sure of, it’s that the Mach has the makings of a truly versatile shoe.
It’s comfortable enough for daily runs, responsive enough to push the pace, and supportive enough for some gym sessions.
We don’t normally gush over running shoes, but when we do, it’s without a doubt, a REALLY excellent shoe. And that’s what we consider the Asics MetaSpeed Sky to be.
Smash PBs, win races - this shoe is everything fast! It’s a speed monster and it didn’t come here to play.
The midsole is where the magic happens. The carbon plate just gives you that rebounding ride, while the FlyteFoam Blast propels and pushes you forward. We kid you not, it sent us zooming through the blocks!
And essential for a race shoe, the MetaSpeed Sky generates a snug, wobble-free fit. The heel and midfoot are nice and secure, while there’s sufficient room in the forefoot to allow some wriggle room. Taking it up a notch, it’s got a comfortable fit - padded in all the right places.
Although loaded with superb features, the shoe does not load it up on our weighing scale. Via our lab test results, the average running shoe comes in at 9.4 oz. Guess what? The MetaSpeed Sky is significantly lighter at 6.7 oz.
$250 is a HUGE price to pay for a pair of running shoes, more so for a race shoe (as they don’t normally last long). But with the Asics MetaSpeed Sky, we’d gladly make an exception.
Sleeky and sexy - that’s not something you’d expect from a trail shoe.
The Pegasus line from Nike is nearing its 40th version, and runners just had to have it in a trail version. Three iterations later, the Nike Pegasus Trail 3 came into the running scene. And we love every bit of it!
It’s a max-cushioned trainer that can eat up miles on the gnarliest terrain. And if you want soft landings on the trail, this will give you just that.
The shoe’s React foam is what dreams are made of! It’s plush, and bouncy, and nothing like a trail shoe. Seriously, it felt like it was a road shoe.
All that softness doesn’t render the ride unstable either. In fact, wel felt confident on uneven surfaces, and when crushing downhills.
It may be peppy, but it definitely has its limits in tempo paces. It’s just got a lot of weight - even for a maximalist trail shoe. In our lab tests, we’ve gathered that max-cushioned shoes normally weigh in at 9.5 oz, whereas the Peg Trail 3 comes at a whopping 10.8 oz!
Nike, that’s just crazy. Maybe put this shoe on a diet, and then we’ll talk.
Thankfully, the outsole is here to make amends. Contrary to the average shoe (with outsole depth: 3.8mm; hardness: 79.2HC), the Nike Pegasus Trail 3 has an outsole thickness of 5.5mm and stiffness of 86HC.
Learning curve needed for heel strikers or slower paces
Slipper on wet surfaces
A speed trainer and a race day shoe? Take both in the Endorphin Speed 2. After pacing it through, this shoe proved itself a star in speed, responsiveness, and durability. It literally sent us flying through the blocks! Even better, it's unlike any speed-oriented shoes we've tested - it doesn't forgo comfort in favor of lightness and agility!
Flat feet can be a painful foot condition if not paired with the right running shoes. And if you’re looking for one, buy the Adrenaline GTS 21!
After some runs in it, it’s one of the few stability shoes that packs so much comfort while keeping the feet so stable, they stay in place the whole time.
It’s not restricting either, which is a huge plus for such a shoe that supports the feet excellently.
What makes the Adrenaline GTS 21 our cream of the crop is that its supportive features are not obtrusive. In fact, they are only activated when the foot moves far off the sides.
This means neutral runners can also enjoy the shoe just as much as overpronators (feet roll inward excessively) and those with flat feet do.
The shoe is on the heavier end, weighing in at 10.2 oz (our lab tests tell us the average max-cushioned running shoe sits at 9.5 oz). But with its performance, we don’t mind one bit! It just ate up everything we threw at it.
It’s built to last, and last it did. After putting it through some rough wear testing, this shoe showed little to no sign of damage. It’s a beast in this department! We expect it to last 400-500 miles.
Come on now, who doesn’t love a budget shoe that has what it takes to pace you through your training runs? Because we sure do, and we hit home with the Axon.
The shoe is built on the Endorphin platform (the brand’s top line of running shoes), and with that alone, we are amazed! It’s fast-transitioning like that of the Endorphin, so it will really roll you through your strides.
Speed-ready? Man, this shoe just kept us on our toes. There’s really no need to push it forward - IT will bolt you forward!
Just to make everything clear, this is anything but plush. But all that stiffness actually contributes to the shoe’s ability to go fast. It goes hand in hand with the rocker geometry and keeps transitions nice and easy.
It’s not everyday that you get a durable shoe for just 100 bucks. We are confident Saucony Axon can last 400-500 miles.
The carbon rubber outsole is stiffer (82.5HC) than the average (75.1HC). And the rigid midsole is not going to bottom out easily.
The Corescore is a score from 0-100 that summarizes opinions from users and experts.Below shows the distribution of scores for all running shoes.
This shoe has a 10% penalty on its user ratings because it has fewer than 50 ratings.
It also has a 10% penalty on its expert reviews because it has fewer than 5 reviews.
This is to avoid that shoes with few reviews unjustly receives high scores.
The Salomon XT-6 has been a hugely popular shoe for nearly a decade both for its looks and its ability to take you anyway on a trail. With heaps of protection, insane grip, and a responsive, speedy ride the XT-6 is still a relevant trail shoe to help you explore the less beaten trails. It’s a shoe that’s sure to leave you confident traversing steep gradients, or comfy at the end of a long hike.
Depending on your footstrike, you should check whether your chosen model has more (or equal amounts of) cushioning in the forefoot or in the heel. You need that pillowy feature exactly where you land on the ground with your feet.
daily trainer from Hoka (left), speed trainer from Saucony (center), elite race shoe from Asics (right)
If you’re used to running in low-profile shoes, you might need to go through a transition period to allow your feet to adapt to new cushioning levels.
What to expect from cushioned running shoes
Comfort. And then some more comfort!
You might feel like foamy clouds are the best thing that happened to your feet. Those cushioning layers surely feel comfortable and soft and allow your feet to run without feeling every little terrain detail.
To up the ante, the newest technologies might even help you run faster (like this analysis showed) thanks to their spring-like effects and additions like carbon plates.
However, scientific circles have examined other effects as well:
Adding weight to your shoes will slow you down, as shown here.
The injury risk was higher in lighter participants running in the hard shoes compared with those using soft shoes. For details, read this study.
Midsole technologies explained
Cushioning is defined by the midsole of the shoe: part of the shoe between the upper and the outsole. The most common midsoles in traditional shoes are made of two types of foam: EVA (ethylene vinyl acetate) or PU (polyurethane).
There are different types of midsoles and the biggest differences are seen in the padding positioning, softness/firmness, and energy return. For beginners, it’s recommended to find a shoe that’s comfortable, and leave other factors for more advanced runs, when the time comes.
Brands tend to develop their own signature materials. That’s how new foams have entered the scene. The biggest step was made once the energy return was measured - Nike’s cushioning technology allows for up to 85% energy return. Most of these innovative midsoles not only cushion your feet but also offer a spring-like response.
Nike Zoom: more responsiveness, less pronation. Designed for speed and agility. This technology allows tightly stretched fibers to snap back for fast movement and reduced stress on muscles, joints, and tendons.
Zoom Air: Nike’s tightly stretched tensile fibers that are knit inside a pressurized Nike Air unit, all with the purpose of snappy responsiveness. Made for more responsive and energetic runs.
ZoomX: magically energetic and the lightest foam created by Nike. It uses cutting-edge engineering which allows for 85% energy return.
Asics’s Gel rearfoot technology reduces impact during heel strike, forefoot Gel technology enhances shock reduction during forward movement. Together they allow for maximum comfort. This cushioning was created for longer distances, stability nad natural run style.
Asics Gel on the Cumulus 23, a popular daily trainer
Asics has several variations of FlyteFoams to offer:
Lyte, which is focused on the heel and retains shape after every run
Propel, with the purpose of greater spring and toe-off (high-energy return and less drag)
If you decide to go for more cushioning, there’s a price to pay: it adds more weight. More weight means you’ll run slower and have to work harder to maintain your speed.
For this analysis, we’ve pulled all cushioned running shoes from our database. Their cushioning level is rated 5-10, 10 being the plushiest. For each grade, we calculated average shoe weight.
To get the sense of what this means, the lightest running shoe in our database is a racing shoe that weighs 76g only (men, for women it’s 69g). The heaviest shoes go as far as 680g (with cushioning level of 7).
How long does cushioning in running shoes last?
The longevity of running shoes is determined by multiple factors: built-up mileage, shoe materials, your weight, running form, terrain.
Cushioning doesn’t last forever and you should consider buying new shoes the moment you:
Start feeling muscle fatigue or pain, especially in your knees, after your average run, or
Feel there’s not enough impact-absorption (your feet hurt or start aching on impact).
Your shoes still might look good on the outside, but on the inside, the cushioning layers might be deteriorating. That’s why it’s important not to focus on visual inspection only.
Whether it's a vertical kilometre or an ultra, climbing in the Alps or exploring local mountains, Jovana uses every opportunity to trade walls and concrete for forests and trails. She logs at least 10h/week on trails, with no off-season, and 4x more on research on running and running shoes. With a background in physics and engineering management, she prefers her running spiced with data.