Altra Escalante 4 review

We believe the Altra Escalante 4 is a fantastic running shoe for:

• Zero drop enthusiasts seeking a stable shoe that delivers an awesome ground feel.
• Those in need of a versatile, low-drop shoe ideal for walking, some gym activities and, of course, running!
• Loyal fans of the Escalante series who were let down by the previous model, as this version returns to the beloved features of the 1.5.

As a zero-drop shoe, the Escalante 4 may not suit runners with recurring Achilles or calf issues. If that's you, we suggest the Nike Flex Experience Run 12, which offers a flexible ride paired with a higher drop—ideal for better heel support.

We also found that the upper, while incredibly comfortable, lacks sufficient ventilation for those in warmer climates. However, Altra addresses this with the Escalante Racer, which boasts perfect ventilation and retains a cozy knit upper, solving this issue while preserving the core Escalante DNA.

The Escalante 4 features a heel with a relatively low stack height of just 23.8 mm, at least by today's standards.

Though this may seem low, it's crucial to remember that Altra tailors its shoes with a zero-drop design, so heel cushioning is not that important because most runners should strike the ground with the midfoot or forefoot with this shoe.

The forefoot of the Escalante 4 maintains a similar profile at 22.4 mm, perfect for those seeking a ride that’s a bit cushioned yet still feels very connected to the ground.

Additionally, the photo below clearly shows what we previously discussed during the outsole thickness test—the rubber is integrated into the foam rather than merely being glued on top.

We discovered a 1.4-mm heel-to-toe drop in the Escalante 4, which is acceptable for a zero-drop shoe due to slight manufacturing variations or foam compression.

Given this minimal drop, the shoe isn't suited for everyone. Zero-drop footwear caters to those who are comfortable with such an offset. For newcomers to this group, we recommend gradually integrating this shoe into your routine to ease the transition, starting just walking and then gradually increasing running.

Moving to the midsole, we discovered that Altra employs its standard EGO foam, which offers a balance between a firm and balanced feel for us (27.8 HA).

For those who favor plush midsoles, the Escalante 4 won't meet expectations. However, we advise against soft midsoles in low-stack shoes, as softer foam could lead to bottoming out and discomfort. If you're seeking a plush yet low-drop option, the Altra Via Olympus 2 provides a cloud-like ride with a zero-drop design.

After spending 20 minutes in our freezer, the firmness of the EGO foam increased by 30.6%—a notable performance for a midsole crafted from EVA, though there's still some room for improvement.

The insole is thick (5.5 mm) and plays a crucial role in the shoe's overall cushioning system.

Our expectations were sky-high for the spaciousness of the upper, as the Escalante 4 boasts Altra's Original FootShape—the brand's roomiest toebox design.

That's why we weren't surprised to measure 103.6 mm at the widest part of the toebox, providing ample room for those blessed (?) with wider feet.

Yet, as with every Altra, our second measurement at the big toe reveals the true fit. At 90.8 mm, the Original FootShape design springs to life, offering what we believe it's one of the roomiest toeboxes we've ever tried in the lab.

While it may appear somewhat unusual or even clown-like from our POV, the comfort it provides for our feet is simply unparalleled, making it challenging to return to an average design with a more tapered and cramped toebox.

One of the key benefits of a shoe that keeps you close to the ground is the immediate increase in stability compared to average running shoes. We can confirm that the Escalante 4 provides a remarkably stable ride for neutral runners.

The Escalante 4 bends and flexes like crazy, scoring a 1/5 from us, which is a crucial component of its natural feel and comfort. And while its flexibility might detract from stability, the low stack height naturally enhances this aspect without necessitating a rigid structure at all.

The heel counter is neither intrusive nor overwhelming; in fact, it's quite the opposite. It collapsed to our slight pressure, prompting us to rate it just 2 out of 5.

Returning to the midsole, we measured its dimensions using calipers, starting with the forefoot.

Our initial measurement revealed a very wide platform at 118.3 mm, which undoubtedly contributes to the remarkable secure feel we experienced during landings on our runs.

Discovering a narrow heel measurement of 82.5 mm on the shoe was not a shock to us in the lab. It seems Altra relies on the stability provided by its moderately firm midsole, and low-drop configuration—all tailored to enhance stability and reflect the natural shape of the foot.

This narrower heel may not suit extreme heel strikers though, but it's likely that such runners may have been attracted to the Escalante series, considering that it's a zero-drop shoe.

We previously discovered that the shoe flexed impressively in our torsional test, yet we still needed to evaluate how it performed in our 90-degree bend test, where we measure resistance with a force gauge in Newtons.

Following the test, we recorded a force of 16.0N, confirming the shoe's exceptional flexibility!

After placing the Escalante 4 in the freezer for 20 minutes, we tested its stiffness again. This time, we observed a 26.4% increase in the shoe's resistance.

While we previously suggested that Altra might consider reducing some weight from the Escalante 4, it’s not something that worries us at all.

At just 8.4 oz (237g), the E4 is remarkably lightweight, although any improvement in the next update would be appreciated here in the lab!

The Escalante 4 replaces the mesh upper of its predecessor with a more comfortable knit upper. Initially, we were concerned that, as is common with knit uppers, this change might reduce ventilation. To verify this, we conducted a series of lab tests.

In our initial evaluation with the upper, we employed a smoke-pumping machine to assess the shoe's ventilation capabilities. This test clearly demonstrated that air flow was less effective than we hoped. As a result, we assigned a modest rating of 3 out of 5, indicating that while the shoe provides some ventilation, it falls short of providing optimal breathability.

Using a simple light test, we discovered another significant reason for the reduced ventilation—the knit is much thicker and more structured when compared to the Racer, with reinforced areas in the toebox, arch, and heel to enhance durability and stability.

However, to fully understand this issue, we need to use multiple tools. Examining the shoe under a microscope, we found the knit to be extremely cozy, yet lacking in sufficient gaps for air and moisture to escape.

In our hands-on assessment, we appreciated the upper's stretchiness and how well it conforms to the feet. However, don't expect it to be ultra-padded, as it's clearly designed for being lightweight.

However, it's clear this shoe is best suited for runners who avoid extremely hot conditions.

Knit uppers often involve a trade-off between comfort and durability, but the Escalante 4 breaks this mold by being both incredibly durable and exceptionally cozy, scoring 4/5 in our lab.

Kudos to Altra for achieving this rare balance, we're actually impressed!

After evaluating the toebox, we shifted our testing to the heel using our Dremel sandpaper tip, another critical area for assessing early wear. 

Fortunately, the Escalante 4 impressed us again with another solid 4/5 score, indicating reliable durability in this area—even for those who tend to dig into heel padding quickly.

With the upper properly analyzed in terms of durability, we now focused into the outsole. Our first measurement placed the outsole hardness at a rock-solid 86.2 HC, which is notably above average.

Why this choice? Well, Altra FootPod outsole, which resembles a human foot in terms of shape and flexibility, can also wear down quicker than a shoe with full-length rubber coverage.

The Escalante 4 features an interesting outsole that blends exposed foam with rubberized sections for added toughness and hard rubber in the areas most susceptible to wear.

We were particularly impressed with this design after our latest Dremel test, where the outsole sustained only a 0.3-mm dent. That's an A++ for us!

To conclude our analysis of the outsole, we measured its thickness, which registered at a substantial 4.6 mm. However, unlike other shoes that simply layer the outsole over the foam, Altra ingeniously sinks the outsole into the foam.

This innovative approach allows for more rubber without making the shoe cumbersome. However, after observing the toughness of the rubber when it faced our Dremel, we believe that a 4.6 mm thickness is excessive and Altra could benefit from slightly reducing this measurement.

Altra is typically known for adding reflective elements to their shoes. However, our lab evaluation reveals that the lower cost of the Escalante brings some minor drawbacks—reflective features being one of them.

The tongue of this shoe breaks away from the average design of daily trainers, sporting only 1.5 mm of padding—reminiscent of competition shoes. 

This makes it suitable only for those comfortable with minimal instep padding. Conversely, runners who tighten their laces tightly might face discomfort due to the thin tongue of the Escalante 4. For a cushy option, try the Saucony Kinvara 14, which features a 3.9-mm tongue.

Unfortunately, we discovered that Altra omitted the gusset in the Escalante 4, a decision that proved disappointing for us as it would have significantly enhanced the shoe's overall lockdown.

Like many Altra road running shoes, we proved that you won't find a heel tab, and the heel collar isn't extended as it is in Hokas, so we found that slipping our feet into the Escalantes is not as effortless as in other kicks.

We discovered that removing the insole from the Altra wasn't an issue since it isn't glued down. 

However, due to its distinctively rounded design in the toebox, integrating an insole from a different shoe or custom orthotics may not work well. Oh, and another reason to keep the stock insole is that it's one of the few on the market that is perforated, enhancing the shoe's ventilation.