Verdict from 1 expert and +100 user reviews

10 reasons to buy

  • The Merrell Siren Edge delivered a right-out-of-the-box comfort. This was appreciated by many based on their positive reviews. One even said that she felt like the shoes were made for her.
  • This pair was one of the most comfortable hiking shoes ever, as mentioned by a significant number of wearers.
  • A substantial number of Siren Edge purchasers commended the Vibram outsole. They said that it was able to grip well on muddy and concrete grounds.
  • The support from these Merrell hiking shoes was lauded by the majority.
  • There were no hot spots, no blisters and no foot pains according to a couple of satisfied users.
  • Several wearers liked the adequate toe box room offered by Siren Edge. They noted that there was enough room for them to wiggle their toes.
  • It required virtually no breaking-in period, according to some users.
  • A couple of Merrell stalwarts were enthusiastic in getting their second pair.
  • The design and colorways of Siren Edge received praises from numerous wearers. One buyer even wanted to have a pair in every color.
  • More than a handful liked that these shoes fit true to size.

2 reasons not to buy

  • Some buyers questioned the Merrell quality. They noted that the pair they purchased started to show signs of wear after a month. One even experienced that the entire upper separated from its sole on the first day.
  • Siren Edge's lack of cushioning on the heel made a few users felt they were walking on a post.

Bottom line

Merrell tailored the profile of the Siren Edge for ladies as a crossover of athletic and hiking shoes. Its straight-out-of-the-box comfort, no break-in period and true-to-size fit were undeniable. A considerable number of users were convinced that getting a second pair is worth it with its steadfast comfort and support. Its grippy outsole received praises too. As perfect as these hiking shoes may seem, it missed achieving the quality Merrell has been known for. Over and above, Merrell Siren Edge is still a go-to shoe from daily chores to light hiking on the trails.

Tip: see the best hiking shoes.

Good to know

  • Merrell guarantees that the Siren Edge is equipped with features that are ideal for long hikes and can keep the feet comfortable. The mesh upper with 3D print mesh overlays offers a breathable combination. The bellows tongue blocks detritus from entering the shoe. 
  • A Merrell-patented footbed with odor control, the M.Select FIT.ECO, retains the freshness of the shoes and provides comfort. Also, the EVA midsole keeps the foot cushioned. The heel reinforcement and molded nylon arch shank stabilize and give a secure foothold on terrains.
  • The Vibram outsole incorporated in the Merrell Siren Edge is a robust component that promises optimal performance. It provides traction on mixed terrains.

Siren Edge from Merrell is a women-specific footgear. It has a traditional lace-up closure and a heel pull loop for a more straightforward fit adjustment. The tongue and collar are padded for plush comfort.

These low-cut hiking shoes are fitted with a Vibram outsole. Providing underfoot protection, it has deep lugs which grip on different types of terrain. The multi-directional tread pattern of this outsole makes it slip-resistant, thus enabling users to have a secure footing on wet surfaces.

The Siren Edge's footbed is called M.Select FIT.ECO from Merrell. Made from blended EVA (ethylene-vinyl acetate), it has an organic odor control feature, keeping the foot dry and fresh. This insole is also contoured to provide support and comfort.

The EVA foam comprises the midsole. It gives a cushioned and comfortable feel. This type of material is also known for its resistance to abrasion. It is able to absorb shock and minimize impacts as well. The air cushion in the heel further enhances the shock absorption.

The Siren Edge by Merrell is also equipped with a molded nylon shank which adds firmness. A nylon shank is lightweight. It is also flexible yet supportive. It allows the enables users to move naturally while not compromising the support for the foot arches, thus reducing the likelihood of foot fatigue.

The upper is crafted with a breathable mesh and 3D print mesh. This design does not limit the breathability of the material used. The 3D print overlays add support and structure to the footgear without the increase in weight.

The Merrell Siren Edge's tongue is connected to the sides of the upper to form the bellows tongue. It prevents trail debris from entering the hiking shoe.


How Merrell Siren Edge ranks compared to all other shoes
Top 6% hiking shoes
All hiking shoes
Top 7% Merrell hiking shoes
All Merrell hiking shoes
Top 5% day hiking hiking shoes
All day hiking hiking shoes


The current trend of Merrell Siren Edge.
Compare to another shoe:
Paul Ronto
Paul Ronto

Paul loves adventure. Over the past 20 years, he has climbed, hiked, and ran all over the world. He’s summited peaks throughout the Americas, trekked through Africa, and tested his endurance in 24-hour trail races. He has worked in the outdoor industry as a whitewater and hunting guide, gear tester, copywriter, and outfitting specialist at places like The National Outdoor Leadership School, No Barriers USA, and Sierra Trading Post. He has been quoted in NYMag, NBCNews, and Business Insider to name a few.