Hoka Gaviota 3 review and lab test

The Bondi for pronators! 

The Hoka Gaviota 3 is a plush, heavily cushioned stability shoe seemingly designed for foam lovers whose social standing is directly correlated to stack height.

Hoka One One Gaviota 3 pieces of the shoe

Think Hoka Bondi 7 with extra support. 

Who the shoe is (not) for 

The Gaviota 3 is ideal for the heavier runner that needs a stability shoe (for overpronation). If you are considering the Brooks Beast or the Saucony Hurricane the Gaviota is worth a look.  

Don’t buy this shoe if:

  • your feet are really narrow or 
  • you’re expecting this plush trainer to be soft and bouncy. It’s stiff for lighter runners. You can consider the Hoka Arahi 5 or the Skechers Forza 4 Hyper instead. 

Hoka One One Gaviota 3 profile picture

Good fit with 2 annoyances 

The Gaviota 3 is a high-volume shoe with plenty of room for wider feet.

I liked how the shoe felt on my foot, but I did have some issues that annoyed me. 

  1. The tongue is gusseted but it’s fixed thanks to a sewn seam near the top of the tongue, meaning it’s hard to position the tongue or get that satisfying tongue pull. I wish Hoka had done the gussets on this shoe as it does on most of its lines where they stretch and allow the tongue to be positioned a bit. 
  2. The H-Frame upper/lacing system is designed to give this shoe added support and a customized lockdown across the midfoot, but I was just annoyed with it. It’s hard to lace up and to unlace when you want to take the shoe off. 

Frustrating lacing system

Heavens forbid you slide the shoe off and then have to unlace it later while it’s off your foot, the lacing system turns into a frustrating game of Cat’s Cradle.

It’s a small gripe to complain about but if these were in my rotation I’d find myself not wanting to wear them because of this specific issue. 

Gaviota 3 is too plushy and too padded

These shoes are insanely plush, to the point of discontent. Sure, they hug your foot nicely and have plenty of foam everywhere, but they seem a bit hot and overly padded in areas. 

The tongue is 10.3mm thick, almost double the average of 5.8mm. 

Upper layers on Hoka One One Gaviota 3

If you want ankle padding, you get it in spades in the Gaviota 3. At 12.7, 13.9, and 18.6mm (front, middle, rear) it's the most padded shoe we’ve tested, where the average measures 8.0, 11.2, and 10.5mm.

Padded heel on Hoka One One Gaviota 3

I personally don’t think anyone needs this much foam around the ankle, it just adds warmth and weight to the shoe. 

Tongue bunches up

The excessive thickness of the tongue leads to a significant bulge in the lower area.

Normally you can just tug on the tongue when this happens, but it’s locked in place and this bulge wouldn’t flatten out for me. 

Ride on Gaviota 3 is too stiff

If you’ve seen my review of the Hoka Bondi 7, you’ll know I wasn’t in love with it’s “max cushioning” ride. It felt stiff and heavy to me and I preferred the Clifton 7 in the comfort and ride department. 

The Gaviota 3 feels the same to me, it’s a bit too stiff for me to really take advantage of the 39.4mm of heel foam under foot. For lighter runners that want a Hoka stability shoe, I’d suggest checking out the Arahi 5, as it’s more in line with the Clifton than the Bondi. 

Hoka Gaviota 3 is a stability shoe 

In terms of stability, Hoka did this on multiple fronts: 

  • J frame construction, 
  • Stiff heel counter, 
  • Wide base. 

Hoka uses a J-frame construction, so no medial post which I like, just some denser foam on the medial edge of the shoe. 

Hoka One One Gaviota 3 half

I will say I can feel this mostly on the inside edge of my heel, and after a few miles, the pressure on my heel was becoming bothersome. 

The shoe also gets some added stability from the insanely stiff heel counter. At 107.9N (compared to the average of 64.1N) there’s no lateral movement in the back of the shoe. Hoka accomplishes this with a 1.9mm plastic heel counter, and a thick, external rubber heel clutch. 

The shoe also has an extremely wide base which also helps. At 117.9mm in the forefoot, and 105.2mm in the heel, you literally can’t roll this shoe over. Compare that to the average or 113.5mm up from and just 90.7mm in the heel. 

Watch your calves at higher speeds

Gaviota 3 is actually so wide in the heel I found it tending to hit my calves as I tried to pick up the pace on my treadmill tests, that’s a first! 

Heel design on Hoka One One Gaviota 3

Heel drop 2x higher than advertised

Hoka claims this is a 5mm drop shoe, but it feels heel heavy.

Hoka One One Gaviota 3 cut in half

Measured in our lab, we got 9.6mm of drop. 

Heavy and looks even heavier

This is not a lightweight shoe, at 11.2 ounces (318g) it's a bruiser. But for what it is, it’s actually pretty impressive. It has more foam, more padding, and more laces (yes they are extremely long still, a problem the Gaviota 2 had as well) than most shoes would ever need. 

Hoka One One Gaviota 3 weight

I would have guessed this shoe to weigh in around 13-14 ounces. 

Gaviota 3 was built to last forever

I assume this shoe will go forever. It’s the shoe you’d want if you lived in the Chernobyl blast radius and you knew you wouldn’t be receiving new shoes in the mail for decades. 

  1. There’s a ton of stiff foam that will take forever to pack out,
  2. there’s hard rubber on the outsole, and
  3. the upper is constructed of two thick layers of fabric. 

It’s going to be around for a while. 

Hoka One One Gaviota 3 outsole

I saw a review of a guy who wore the Gaviota 2 for 1000 miles and the 3 has an additional 2mm of foam underfoot. 

Not so breathable

The Gaviota 3 got a new upper which to me felt warm. The 2 was more of a knit mesh and the 3 is a denser engineered polyester.

Upper on Hoka One One Gaviota 3

This is a two-layered upper and I think Hoka could have removed the inner layer to lose weight and keep the shoe cooler on warm days. 

Hard work needed for a proper lockdown

I mentioned the annoyance I had with the laying system earlier, it’s designed to help with lockdown, and it works, but you really have to crank on the laces to lock in your heel in the Gaviota 3, and that can be a challenge with how the laces are set up. 

Lacing on Hoka One One Gaviota 3

At times it’s hard to get your fingers under the specific part of the lace you want to adjust, which defeats its purpose.

I had to fiddle with these a lot to get my foot to stay put. 

Hoka Gaviota 3 was not made for cold days 

Like the Bondi, this shoe is not a top performer in cold weather. In our lab tests, the shoe stiffens up 94.1% when cold, compared to the average of just 60.7%.

Conclusion 

I’ll end with saying, this shoe could be great for bigger runners that pronate, but for anyone else, I’d steer towards some of Hoka’s other offerings. Also, there are no reflective elements on this shoe, so beware in the evenings if you are an after-work runner.

Complete lab-specs overview 

Hoka One One Gaviota 3
Weight - Left 318
Weight - Right 319
Weight - Insole 25
Weight - Lace  5
Length - Overall 297.92
Length - Insole 276.43
Width Midsole - Forefoot  117.9
Width Midsole - Heel 105.2
Width Midsole - Middle  87.5
Width Upper - Forefoot 97.3
Width Upper - Heel 79.3
Width Upper - Middle 79.5
Stack - Forefoot with insole 29.8
Stack - Heel with insole 39.4
Stack - Forefoot without insole 24.9
Stack - Heel without insole 34.4
Insole Thickness 4.6
Drop 9.6
Outsole thickness (Forefoot) 4.28
Outsole thickness (Heel) 3.49
Lugs Depth N/A
Laces (without stretch) 57
Laces (with stretch) 69
Lace Stretch  21.05%
Laces - Thickness (Height) 1.3
Laces - Width 6.1
Room temperature 59.4
Durometer Outsole Forefoot (Room temperature) 78.5
Durometer Outsole Heel (Room temperature) 83.3
Outsole % of change from Heel to Forefoot (Room temperature) 6.16%
Durometer Midsole Forefoot (Room temperature) 23.3
Durometer Midsole Forefoot 2nd layer (Room temperature) 32.8
Durometer Midsole Heel (Room temperature) 21.8
Durometer Insole (Room temperature) 25.3
Flexibility of the shoe  42.3
Durometer Outsole Forefoot (Freezer 1 hour) 84.0
Durometer Outsole Heel (Freezer 1 hour) 85.3
Durometer Midsole Forefoot (Freezer 1 hour) 29.0
Durometer Midsole Forefoot 2nd layer (Freezer 1 hour) 40.8
Durometer Midsole Heel (Freezer 1 hour) 27.0
Durometer Insole (Freezer 1 hour) 27.0
Flexibility of the shoe (Freezer 1 hour) 82.0
Durometer Outsole Forefoot (% change with temperature) 7.01%
Durometer Outsole Heel (% change with temperature) 2.40%
Durometer Midsole Forefoot (% change with temperature) 24.29%
Durometer Midsole Heel (% change with temperature) 23.66%
Durometer Insole (% change with temperature) 6.58%
Flexibility of the shoe (% change with temperature) 94.13%
Thickness - Heel Counter/Insert 1.9
Thickness - Ankle Collar (Front) 12.7
Thickness - Ankle Collar (Middle) 13.9
Thickness - Ankle Collar (Back) 18.6
Thickness - Tongue 10.3
Flexibility of the heel counter  107.9
Lace slip test with the knot 13.6
Longitudinal flexibility (0-5) 2
Torsional flexibility (0-5) 2
Heel counter material Plastic with external rubber heel clutch
Tongue: gusset type both sides
Tongue gusset material Polyester
Laces: profile  Flat
Laces: material Nylon
Laces: extra hole  yes
Laces: are they long enough to use the extra hole  yes
Heel: pull tab  finger loop
Insole: removable yes
Control devices:
Multi-density midsole
Rigid heel counter
Elevated medial insole under arch
Supportive tensioned medial upper
Medial flare
Thermoplastic medial post
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
How minimalist the shoe is in % 20

Note: all the tests were done on a men's shoe US size 9. 

Tip: see the best running shoes.

Rankings

How Hoka One One Gaviota 3 ranks compared to all other shoes
Top 30% road running shoes
All road running shoes
Bottom 41% Hoka One One running shoes
All Hoka One One running shoes
Top 24% motion control running shoes
All motion control running shoes

Popularity

The current trend of Hoka One One Gaviota 3.
Compare to another shoe:
Author
Paul Ronto
Paul Ronto

Over the past 20 years, Paul has climbed, hiked, and ran all over the world. He has summited peaks throughout the Americas, trekked through Africa, and tested his endurance in 24-hour trail races as well as 6 marathons. On average, he runs 30-50 miles a week in the foothills of Northern Colorado. His research is regularly cited in The New York Times, Washington Post, National Geographic, etc. On top of this, Paul is leading the running shoe lab where he cuts shoes apart and analyses every detail of the shoes that you might buy.