Verdict from 100+ user reviews

7 reasons to buy

  • Almost all of the owners lauded the Propet Connely Strap; it was one of the most comfortable walking shoes they have ever owned.
  • The rugged looks of the trainer resonated well with a majority of wearers.
  • A myriad of buyers claimed that this model was very durable; it lasted about a year or more.
  • Plenty of reviewers liked how this merchandise fit; it was roomy in the toe box but snug at the heel.
  • A lot of shoppers appreciated the easy-to-adjust straps.
  • The removable insoles were a welcome feature for multiple folks.
  • Several persons stated that this product was worth the price they paid for it.

5 reasons not to buy

  • A considerable number of people complained about the inconsistent width and length of the Propet Connelly Strap; some said it was long and wide while others mentioned it was short and narrow.
  • The strap displeased a minority of users; it was very long, but the Velcro did not cover its entire length, so those with very slim feet found it hard to tighten.
  • The trainer was stiff and needed to be broken in, according to several consumers.
  • Because of durability issues like the interior lining deteriorating quickly or the outside stitchings unraveling, some testers considered this footgear pricey.
  • Seams inside the shoe irritated the toes, noted a few individuals.

Bottom line

The Propet Connelly Strap delighted many purchasers with its rustic style and durability. Purchasers enjoyed how easy it was to put on and remove. The removable insoles also gained this footwear some positive feedback. However, despite the claims that it fit comfortably, there were complaints that it was not true to size and width. Other issues with this model included the long strap but short Velcro and the stiffness of the platform. But in the end, the shoe came highly recommended by those who enjoyed wearing a comfortable pair of strap-closure shoes.

Tip: see the best walking shoes.

Good to know

  • The Propet Connelly Strap is modeled after outdoor walking shoes. It uses sturdy components like the suede upper that securely holds the foot. The mesh panels ensure that the interior is kept fresh.
  • For cushioning, it employs a full-length ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA) foam. It has two removable insoles, with one or both can be taken out for a proper fit.
  • The outsole of the Connelly Strap is made of rubber. It has a tread pattern that provides grip on various surfaces as well as flex grooves at the forefoot for a smooth forward motion.
  • It shares many features with the original Propet Connelly. The only difference between the two iterations is the closure. This version uses two straps instead of a lacing system.

The Propet Connelly Strap caters to male users and is available in US sizes 7 to 15, including half and full size in between. As for the width, it comes in a standard D - Medium profile. Those in search of walking shoes in wide would be happy to know that it also comes in 3E - X-Wide and 5E - X-Wide.

A high-traction rubber makes up the outsole of the Propet Connelly Strap. This trainer is designed for outdoor use; thus the material is crafted to be durable and has a tread pattern that grips most surfaces. It also has flex grooves at the forefoot for better heel-to-toe transition.

The full-length EVA foam provides a comfortable underfoot cushioning on the Propet Connelly Strap. It is lightweight and designed to attenuate the impact of each step.

Inside the trainer are two removable insoles that allow users to customize the depth. The top insole is the OrthoLite foam which has an open-cell construction that promotes breathability. It is covered with a Dri-Lex fabric that prevents odor formation because of its antimicrobial properties. The bottom insole is a layer of memory foam that heightens shock attenuation.

Keeping the foot supported while wearing the Propet Connelly Strap is the suede leather upper. It is crafted to hold its shape while the mesh panels aid in ventilating the interior.

For fit adjustment, the trainer is equipped with two hook-and-loop straps instead of a traditional lace-up closure. These structures make for an easy on-and-off action and fit customization. The plushness of both tongue and collar prevents chafing and blisters and they also help hold the foot steady.

The Propet Connelly Strap bears the A5500 code. This marking means that under the Therapeutic Shoe Bill, people with severe diabetes can have the cost of this model reimbursed.


How Propet Connelly Strap ranks compared to all other shoes
Bottom 11% walking shoes
All walking shoes
Bottom 16% Propet walking shoes
All Propet walking shoes
Bottom 9% neutral walking shoes
All neutral walking shoes


The current trend of Propet Connelly Strap.
Compare to another shoe: