Summary

We spent 8.6 hours reading reviews from experts and users. In summary, this is what cyclers think:

7 reasons to buy

  • Almost all owners of the Giro Carbide R II bike shoes claim that it is comfortable.
  • Several purchasers delight at the pair’s excellent quality in materials and construction.
  • Some buyers express their satisfaction with the shoe’s relatively low price and deem it to have good value for money.
  • This Giro cycling shoe’s wearers appreciate how easy it is to walk in this model due to its grippy soles and recessed cleats.
  • The mesh panels throughout the upper provide excellent ventilation, according to a number of users.
  • A couple of cyclists notice the model’s good pedaling performance due to the adequately stiff soles.
  • This MTB footwear is durable, say a few testers.

2 reasons not to buy

  • Some gripe about the shoe not being offered in half sizes.
  • A few reviewers demand more color options.

Bottom line

Giro introduces a second iteration to the Carbide lineage through the Carbide R II. It continues the range’s legacy of comfort and supportive fit but at a more affordable price. 

With updates such as improved breathability, gripper soles, and lower weight, new and long-time fans are satisfied. If you are seeking a budget-friendly entry-level MTB shoe that’s equipped for any terrain, then this pair could fit the bill.

For more, check our guide to the best cycling shoes

Facts

Reviews from around the internet

User reviews:

SportsShoes, Zappos and 17 other shops don't have user reviews

The Giro Carbide R II is an off-road shoe with roots coming from one of the brand’s classic XC models called Carbide. This latest iteration features updates in construction and materials to provide a better riding experience.

Its new synthetic fiber upper with mesh panels help reduce bulk and improve breathability. Classic Velcro straps make adjusting easy without compromising efficiency.

The injected nylon sole provides adequate stiffness for good power transfer. Meanwhile, the durable rubber outsole lugs offer excellent grip whenever the need to walk arises.

Competently responsive pedaling power. A co-molded nylon sole yields adequate stiffness for better power transfer and efficiency to forge onwards.

Superb grip. With high-traction rubber lugs adorning the bottom of the shoe, an enhanced level of grip and feel of the terrain is provided.

Better durability. Midfoot scuff guards are set on the outsoles to protect them from abrasions while off the bike and during clipping in and out of the pedals. This helps in prolonging the shoe’s lifespan and can withstand the worst wear and tear.

Accommodates steel toe spikes. This pair of shoes can be installed with additional toe spikes for extra traction in muddy trails. The spikes are sold separately.

The Giro Carbide R II uses an SPD configuration. It is suitable for the following pedals: DMR V-Twin, Crank Brother Mallet E, and Shimano XTR M9020.

Well-ventilated. With an upper made from high-quality, durable synthetic fiber punctuated with mesh panels, overheating will not be an issue. 

Impact protection. This shoe is crafted with a sturdy toe box and heel design to keep the wearer’s foot safe from bumps, strikes, and injuries.

Efficient and straightforward closure. A classic three-strap retention system provides an easy and on-the-fly adjustment. It is lighter compared to cycling shoes with hardware for closures.

The Carbide R II by Giro employs a die-cut ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA) footbed for enhanced cushioning and pedaling comfort.

This pair’s predecessor is dubbed as the Giro Carbide. It was first introduced in 2012, making it one of the brand’s pioneer models. The Carbide was heralded as one of the best MTB shoes during its time.

The older version closely resembles the newer ones, but an apparent difference is how the latter has upgraded outsole lug traction for a better grip.

The R in the shoe’s official name means “rubber.”

Author
Jens