Verdict from 2 experts and +100 user reviews

6 reasons to buy

  • The majority of the users liked the fit and excellent ankle support provided by the sock extension of the firm ground cleats.
  • Some find this version better than its predecessor with a handful of commenters saying that it is lighter and plusher on foot.
  • One reviewer noted the comfortable footbed of the Puma One 17.4 Firm Ground.
  • The price of this firm ground cleats is budget-friendly.
  • Few users favored the synthetic upper due to its leather-like look and feel.
  • Some players with wide feet said that it suits their size after breaking in.

3 reasons not to buy

  • A couple of users felt that the soleplate tends to trip to the sides due to the stud pattern.
  • A good number of reviewers stated that the design is a bit weird; they find the style elements to be incoherent.
  • Some users noted the longer break-in time needed to feel comfortable with the One 17.4 FG.

Bottom line

The Puma One 17.4 FG aims to live by the 3F’s of the One series: Fit, Feel and Fast.  It passed the basic expectations of being a Puma One silo. The extended sock was primarily a highlight, with many saying it’s comfortable. The synthetic upper was also appreciated as it provided a much thinner sensation than the previous version. It also delivers a great in-shoe feel. Indeed, for someone who values comfort in a firm ground cleat, the One 17.4 is the way to go.

Tip: see the best soccer cleats.

Good to know

  • The main distinction between the One 17.4 FG and the 17.3 FG is their upper material. The latter is made from leather while One 17.4 FG is covered with synthetic. Although different components are used, the overall look is similar. The said material used in this firm ground cleat is made to look like leather.
  • Additionally, the same forefoot stitched pattern is seen in this updated version, giving it an overall heritage look in modern colors.
  • Another similarity seen with the previous versions is the sock extension. Another similarity seen with the previous versions is the sock extension. which is also commonly seen in other One soccer cleats such as the Puma One 18.1 K-Leather Firm Ground and Puma Future 18.1 Netfit FG/AG. Puma has developed this cleat feature to wrap the foot from the ankles. It does serve as a real sock but with a more stretchable material to allow more room for movement. Its secondary function is to protect the cleat from any firm ground debris.
  • The TPU (Thermoplastic Urethane) soleplate is patterned with conical studs that are intended for speed. TPU is a solid material known for its abrasion resistance quality. With this type of outsole, firm ground traction is attested.

The Puma One 17.4 Firm Ground is available in men’s sizing, from 7 to 13. The upper made of synthetic material mimics a leathery look and fit. The sock extension is enclosed in the opening to provide snug fit from the ankles to the inside. Laces are in the midfoot to make room for adjustability.

The stud configuration for One 17.4 FG is termed as “speed-focused”. It is primarily due to its conical stud arrangement that aims to improve agility. Four conical studs are arranged in the heel area while eight studs are placed in the forefoot area. This overall arrangement, coupled with the lightweight TPU soleplate is intended for quick attacking runs.

This firm ground cleat’s upper is entirely synthetic which makes it a lightweight cleat. Its texture imitates the leather sensation found in its predecessor. Stitch details are patterned in the forefoot area similar to that of Puma King cleats. In totality, it imbibes a classic firm ground cleat style.

A sock extension is apparent in the shoe opening which doubles as a mid-cut collar. It is the cleat’s comfort and fit element due to its stretchable nature. Added to that is a pull tab attached to the internal heel counter to allow more space when putting on the close-fitting sock extension.

Laces are positioned in the center of the cleats, above an enclosed synthetic tongue for a solid lockdown.

  • The following color options are available for One 17.4 FG: Puma White-Puma Black-Fiery Coral, Puma Black-Puma Black-Shocking Orange and Silver-Blue Depths


How Puma One 17.4 Firm Ground ranks compared to all other shoes
Top 45% firm ground soccer cleats
All firm ground soccer cleats
Top 18% Puma soccer cleats
All Puma soccer cleats
Top 30% low soccer cleats
All low soccer cleats


The current trend of Puma One 17.4 Firm Ground.
Compare to another shoe: