Verdict from 100+ user reviews

6 reasons to buy

  • A considerable number of consumers got a fantastic fit in the Appalachian, especially in extra wide.
  • Almost everyone who reviewed this New Balance gear reported of its wonderfully comfortable confines.
  • This closed-toe sandal was considered a good form of investment by many.
  • The New Balance Appalachian earned accolades from several owners for being astonishingly light.
  • Several wearers resonated well with the sandal’s eye-catching aesthetics.
  • Its easy-access design, meaning it can be easily put on or removed, impressed about a handful of users. Some of them even likened the sandal to a tennis shoe in terms of on-and-off convenience.

1 reason not to buy

  • Many hikers weren’t thrilled to discover the underwhelming lockdown security of the footwear. They blamed the sandal’s flimsy lacing system for this issue.

Bottom line

Trail lovers in need of something extraordinarily comfortable from New Balance may very well find it in the Appalachian. Indeed, the sandal has comfort in spades, but what further promotes it to must-buy status comes from its accommodating wide fit. There is, unfortunately, just one pebble in this footwear that possibly many people will not at all appreciate—its uninspiring lacing system. All in all, the New Balance Appalachian (despite the challenge it poses during lace-ups) is still leaps and bounds a remarkable hiking sandal, thanks to its compelling combination of outdoor-centric qualities.

Tip: see the best hiking sandals.

Good to know

  • The Appalachian is equipped adequately for trail adventures but at the same time versatile enough for everyday use. It is a lightweight sandal that is shoe-like in appearance thanks to its closed-toe design.
  • Comfort and security on the trail are achieved with the gear’s sole unit. It is made up of the Ndurance outsole—a New Balance exclusive—and an EVA midsole with a molded footbed.

An adequately true-to-size hiking sandal for men is the New Balance Appalachian. It comes in D – standard and 4E – extra wide widths. It is offered in whole sizes. Wearers may get a dialed-in fit with the footwear’s bungee lacing system.

New Balance engineers equipped the Appalachian with the company-owned Ndurance outsole. This heavy-duty rubberized layer grips on most types of terrain with its aggressively shaped protrusions, also known as lugs.

For underfoot cushioning and shock absorption on the trail, this New Balance gear features a heavy-duty midsole. It is made of ethylene-vinyl acetate or EVA—a type of material that grants this component a blend of flexibility and toughness. Its ability to stabilize wearers on rugged terrain is all thanks to its sturdy construction. For extra cushioning, this cushy platform also comes with a molded footbed.

The Appalachian’s upper is made of synthetic PU. This piece from New Balance has an enclosed forefoot zone, protecting hikers from toe-related injuries. Its interior walls provide a nice in-shoe feel as they are lined with Lycra fabric, a proprietary material characterized by lightness and durability among other things.

Fit personalization comes by means of the Appalachian’s bungee toggle closure. It is made of elastic bungee cords for laces and fabric loops for eyelets.


How New Balance Appalachian ranks compared to all other shoes
Bottom 8% hiking sandals
All hiking sandals
Top 1% New Balance hiking sandals
All New Balance hiking sandals
Bottom 3% multi-sport hiking sandals
All multi-sport hiking sandals


The current trend of New Balance Appalachian.
Compare to another shoe:
Paul Ronto
Paul Ronto

Over the past 20 years, Paul has climbed, hiked, and ran all over the world. He has summited peaks throughout the Americas, trekked through Africa, and tested his endurance in 24-hour trail races as well as 6 marathons. On average, he runs 30-50 miles a week in the foothills of Northern Colorado. His research is regularly cited in The New York Times, Washington Post, National Geographic, etc. On top of this, Paul is leading the running shoe lab where he cuts shoes apart and analyses every detail of the shoes that you might buy.