Arch support
Daily running
M: 360g | W: 318g
Heel to toe drop
M: 6mm | W: 6mm
Heel height
M: 24mm | W: 22mm
Forefoot height
M: 18mm | W: 16mm
Widths available
M: Normal - D | W: Normal - B
Show moreless facts


Shoes best for road, track and light gravel. See the best road shoes.


Shoes best for trail, off road, mountains and other unstable surfaces. See the best trail shoes.

Good to know

As long as you stick to the road or path, and if you want just one running shoe, buy a road running shoe.

Neutral / cushion / high arch

Shoes for runners who does not need any additional arch support (Around 50% of runners). Best for people with high or medium high arches. See the best neutral shoes.

Stability / overpronation / normal arch

Shoes for runners who needs arch support (Around 45% of runners). Best for runners with a normal arch. See the best stability shoes.

Motion control / severe overproanation / flat feet

Shoes for runners who needs a lot of arch support. Best for runners with flat feet. See the best motion control shoes.

Good to know

- Rule of thumb: If in doubt, buy neutral shoes to avoid injuries.
- More about arch support in this video.
- Find your arch type by following steps from this video.

Daily running

Cushioned shoes for your daily easy running. Great comfort. See best shoes for daily running.


Lightweight shoes good for races, interval training, tempo runs and fartlek. Here are the best competition running shoes.

Good to know

If you want just one pair of shoes, buy a shoe for daily running.

The height difference from the heel to the forefoot, also known as heel drop, toe spring, heel to toe spring or simply drop.

There are many opinions about what a good heel drop is. We do not recommend any in particular. Lean more in this video.


We spent 6.9 hours reading reviews from experts and users. In summary, this is what runners think:

7 reasons to buy

  • The upper unit of this running shoe is made out of mesh and TPU, with reflective detailing that improves visibility in low light conditions.

  • Many runners welcomed the synthetic leather laces and the option to have the insole removed.

  • The TrailProtect ™ pad gives reliable underfoot protection from debris along the trails.

  • The Vibram brand of outsole makes use of high-performance materials to make up a very durable outer layer.

  • Reviewers appreciated the M Select Dry, the moisture wicking capability of the upper unit.

  • The All Out Terra Ice doesn’t use any animal products, making it a great choice for vegan athletes.

  • Though aggressive when it comes to its looks, it’s still very appealing to the eyes.

4 reasons not to buy

  • There were testers who complained that the outsole wasn’t as durable as it was supposed.

  • The mid-sole tended to break down easily for some reviewers.

  • The All Out Terra Ice is a pretty heavy running shoe.

  • It has a very expensive price.

Bottom line

Many athletes went to the All Out Terra Ice from Merrell for underfoot comfort and protection against the trails. It’s a heavy, but effective running shoe that’s great for neutral runners.

World wide, All Out Terra Ice is in the bottom 20% most popular running shoes. The brand, Merrell, is the 12th most popular.

Map: Shows popularity per continent based on 1010 shoes


4 / 5 based on 14 ratings

5 star
4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star

Contribute and get a chance to win running shoes every month.

My rating:

Expert reviews

Experts are running shoe geeks, who post reviews at youtube, directly at RunRepeat or at their own websites. Each expert is categorized from level 1 to level 5 based on expertise. See stats on expert reviews and how we calculate scores here.

Are you an expert? Apply to contribute here.

82 / 100 based on 7 expert reviews

  • 85
    Get Out There GearLevel 1 expert
    by Get Out There Gear
    As far as snow goes, this is where the shoe really excels. When I was running uphill, downhill and cross on snow and ice, there was no problem. I felt good bite and never slipped once.
  • 84
    Canadian RunningLevel 4 expert
    by Running Magazine
    The waterproof upper has a minimal, sleek design and that signature Merrell fit, which will appeal to runners who like a roomy and flexible forefoot.
  • 80
    Kate HalseLevel 4 expert
    by Heavy
    Conquer icy surface with ease thanks to built-in tungsten carbide spikes with a carbon toe for superior grip on slippery surfaces.
  • 86
    Steve GraepelLevel 3 expert
    by Gear Junkie
    Unless you are plowing through ankle-deep snow, the All Out Terra Ice is a hearty shoe for winter training.
  • 85
    Outside OnlineLevel 3 expert
    by Outside Online
    A winter warrior that will rescue much of your cold-weather running.
  • 80
    Steve GraepelLevel 3 expert
    by Gear Junkie
    Merrell’s All Out Terra Ice is a sturdy winter runner that shines on verglassed road and trails. The synthetic outer repels the elements and the sturdy front rand protects the digits from hidden toe bashers lurking beneath the white stuff.
  • 65
    OutsideLevel 1 expert
    by Outside
    One obvious quirk: the loose heel gave an unusually insecure rear-foot fit—a strange feeling but not a deal breaker.
  • Show moreless reviews
Apply to become an expert

These are visual presentations, not reviews

  • BJ Shop Zappos
    At the bottom of this shoe, you do get the Trail Protect Pad that offers underfoot protection, along with the tungsten carbide spikes with carbon toe for grip on the icy terrain.
  • Richard Shop Zappos
    You also have this Trail Protect Pad that'll give you great underfoot durability and protection.

Updates to All Out Terra Ice

Merrell’s popular All Out Terra line brings 9 carbide spikes in the outsole to make running on ice such a treat in the Terra Ice. By adding these tungsten-made spikes, the highly-sought performance of the All Terra in the outdoors becomes even more so during winter season.

More than just the spikes, the outsole is fitted with very aggressive 6mm rubber lugs for the ultimate outdoor grip on wet rocks, technical trail, gravel, and even mud.

The new inner sock, just like the one found in the trail version, offers exceptional wraparound feel and enhanced foot security. Piling on the miles in winter is more comfortable with the interior plush feel that is enhanced by this cozy inner sock.

As cushioning is enhanced in the All Out series, which is quite evident in the All Out Terra Ice, most runners will still feel decent flexibility and adequate close to the ground experience for better feedback.

All Out Terra Ice size and fit

The All Out Terra Ice delivers Merrell’s signature close fit in the heel and midfoot with a roomy toe box. With the kind of secured feel in the right areas, runners who love speed should be more confident in their strides. On the other hand, the roomy toe box caters to the need of different runners and provides a very plush room for the toes to splay. Available widths are D for the men’s and B for the women’s. Sizes are on the money with the All Out Terra Ice. Options can be 6 to 14 for the men’s and 5 to 11 for the women’s.


Merrell incorporates the spectacular aggressiveness of 6mm lugs and the stickiness of the Vibram outsole for an incredible grip on different surfaces. As if that were not enough, 9 carbide spikes are also located underfoot to make the Terra Ice a serious operator in icy or snowy conditions.


A Trail Protect Pad is located just above the outsole for a little cushioning and enhanced underfoot protection.


The upper of the All Out Terra is made of synthetic mesh for great breathability and TPU overlays for better structure and support. Merrell also uses a waterproofing membrane below the mesh upper to fight off water or snow. An M-Select Dry Membrane keeps the interior dry as it wicks away moisture. Since there is a chance that the runner faces low-visibility conditions during winter, the reflective materials will be very handy. The removable footbed adds step-in comfort and secure feel and can also be replaced with customized orthotics.


Comparison to category means
  • {{ item.display }}
    {{ item.name }}

These are the most similar shoes to {{ctrl.stripTitle(ctrl.currentShoe.title, ctrl.currentShoe.brand)}} based on it's own characteristics.

  • {{item.title}}
  • {{item.title}}
{{ctrl.convertCurrency(ctrl.getAxisAvgValue('Y'))|currency:ctrl.currencySymbol:ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortY].accuracy}} {{ctrl.getAxisAvgValue('Y')|number:ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortY].accuracy}}{{ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortY].units}} 91 {{ctrl.convertCurrency(ctrl.getAxisMaxValue('Y'))|currency:ctrl.currencySymbol:ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortY].accuracy}} {{ctrl.getAxisMaxValue('Y')|number:ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortY].accuracy}}{{ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortY].units}} 94 {{ctrl.convertCurrency(ctrl.getAxisAvgValue('X'))|currency:ctrl.currencySymbol:ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortX].accuracy}} {{ctrl.getAxisAvgValue('X')|number:ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortX].accuracy}}{{ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortX].units}} $104 {{ctrl.convertCurrency(ctrl.getAxisMaxValue('X'))|currency:ctrl.currencySymbol:ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortX].accuracy}} {{ctrl.getAxisMaxValue('X')|number:ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortX].accuracy}}{{ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortX].units}} $151
{{ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortY]['title']}} {{ctrl.sortOptions[ctrl.sortX]['title']}}
Load interactive matrix
Modify filters
Change what to compare by