We spent 9.5 hours reading reviews from experts and users. In summary, this is what sneaker fanatics think:

8 reasons to buy

  • A majority of owners lauded the comfort offered by the Keen Elsa II Waterproof Chelsea during long periods of walking in wet and cold conditions.
  • The Chelsea style was deemed fashionable by numerous shoppers.
  • The fact that the cleat was easy to put on or remove resonated well with many wearers.
  • Plenty of users who bought their usual size claimed that it was true to size.
  • The rounded toe box offered the right amount of wiggle room for the toes, others noted.
  • The rubber outsole provided excellent traction while walking on wet surfaces, said a lot of reviewers.
  • Though the interior lining was not thick, multiple folks were satisfied with how this pair of Keen shoes kept their feet warm.
  • Several purchasers were pleased with the arch support in this model.

4 reasons not to buy

  • A significant number of critics described the Elsa II Waterproof Chelsea from Keen as clunky.
  • According to a minority of consumers, the heel of the footwear was too wide and caused the hindfoot to slip.
  • Although it fits true to size, several testers had to return their purchase because the opening was too narrow.
  • Some buyers were not fans of the rubber outsole because it squeaked on wood or vinyl floors.

Bottom line

A part of Keen’s lifestyle footwear lineup, the Keen Elsa II Waterproof Chelsea pleased a lot of people because of its cute style. It is considered an excellent cleat for walking in the rain and light snow.

Though the rounded toe box allowed for toe splaying, it was deemed too clunky-looking by others. But overall, this sneaker was generally well-received because of the comfort it offered.


Top: Mid
Inspired from: Casual
Collection: Keen Elsa
Closure: Slip-on
Material: EVA, Leather, Rubber Sole
Season: Winter
Price: $120
Colorways: Black, Brown, Grey, Multi
Small True to size Large
Tight Loose
Neutral Stable
Stiff Flexible
Warm Breathable
Firm Plush
Durability 8/10
Comfort 8/10
Traction 8/10
See more facts

Expert Reviews

Experts are sneaker fanatics, who post reviews at youtube, directly at RunRepeat or at their own websites. Each expert is categorized from level 1 to level 5 based on expertise. See stats on expert reviews and how we calculate scores here.

Are you an expert? Apply to contribute here.

  • First look | Shop Zappos |

  • First look | QVCtv

Become an expert

The Keen Elsa II Waterproof Chelsea is available in women’s sizes. The width is only available in B - Medium. There are no straps or laces on this mid-top footwear, but the elastic side panels ensure a snug fit and allow the mouth to open more extensive when needed. There were some who recommended wearing thick socks because the fit was a bit wide.

Women’s ankle cleats, like the Keen Elsa II Waterproof Chelsea, have been around since the Victorian era. Its close-fitting silhouette pairs well with tucked skinny jeans, tights, skirts of any length, straight-cut pants, and even dresses. Crew-neck shirts, tank tops, and blouses, layered with a cardigan, jacket, coat, or blazer works with this style of footwear.

The Keen Elsa II Waterproof Chelsea is suitable for use in cold and wet conditions because of its seam-sealed and weatherproof upper material. Its sole unit is made of thick vulcanized rubber that gives it a sneaker-like vibe with a heat-reflective strobel inside that enhances insulation. The inside is treated with Cleansport NXT, a technology that provides odor control.

A relatively young company, Keen has been making outdoor and lifestyle trainers since 2003. The brand has expanded its offerings from sandals and now include cold-weather footgear like the Keen Elsa II Weatherproof Chelsea.

Aside from making footwear and accessories that can brave any weather, the company has partnered with organizations that aim to conserve and preserve nature. Keen has also been known for its relief efforts and programs that help veterans get back on their feet.

  • Use a stiff brush or dry cloth to spot clean. Mild soap and cold water can also be used to remove stubborn dirt. Air-dry afterward.
  • The fleece-wrapped polyurethane (PU) footbed is removable.


Danny McLoughlin

Danny is a sneakerhead turned sneaker industry expert that believes a good outfit begins from the feet up. His aunt currently isn't speaking to him for wearing a pair of kicks at his cousin's wedding. He spends most of his time trying to keep on top of the latest releases, hitting up his contacts and doing what needs to be done to secure his next pickup. Danny has been featured in prestigious publications such as The Washington Post, The Irish Times, Footwear News and the like.