Summary

We spent 5.9 hours reading reviews from experts and users. In summary, this is what runners think:

5 reasons to buy

  • The outsole of the Hoka One One Stinson ATR 5 provides outstanding traction in muddy surfaces, according to a customer.
  • Several runners commended the shoe’s underfoot support.
  • The Stinson ATR 5 offers excellent cushioning, wrote many commenters.
  • Many users have praised the comfortable in-shoe feel delivered by the shoe.
  • A couple of buyers were pleased with how the shoe relieves their plantar fasciitis.

4 reasons not to buy

  • The toe box is too narrow, a couple of reviewers said.
  • The insole makes a squeaky sound that had to be remedied to make it less bothersome, a buyer mentioned.
  • One user complained about the stiff heel of the Stinson ATR 5.
  • The design of the shoe looks “dorky,” a buyer commented.

Bottom line

If one would compare it to the previous version, the Hoka One One Stinson ATR 5 seems to get a lower satisfaction rating among users. Although there were various positive reviews about the shoe’s functionality, there were just as much negative comments about its design and structure. Overall, the Stinson ATR 5 looks to be a good running shoe, but maybe just average at best.

Facts

Terrain: Trail
Arch support: Neutral
Weight: Men: 12.1oz | Women: 9.9oz
Heel to toe drop: Men: 5mm | Women: 5mm
Pronation: Neutral Pronation
Arch type: High arch
Use: Jogging
Material: Vegan
Strike Pattern: Midfoot strike
Distance: Daily running | Long distance | Marathon
Heel height: Men: 35mm | Women: 35mm
Forefoot height: Men: 30mm | Women: 30mm
Release date: Jan 2019
Brand: Hoka One One
Type: Heavy | Big guy | Low drop | Maximalist
Width: Men: Normal | Women: Normal
Price: $160
Colorways: Black, Blue, Green, Grey, Multi, Purple
Size
Small True to size Large
See more facts

Expert Reviews

Experts are runners, who post reviews at youtube, directly at RunRepeat or at their own websites. Each expert is categorized from level 1 to level 5 based on expertise. See stats on expert reviews and how we calculate scores here.

Are you an expert? Apply to contribute here.

83 / 100 based on 4 expert reviews

  • 90 / 100 | The Ultra Running Company | | Level 2 expert

    I consider this a fantastic shoe at the end of a ong run when your feet have expanded due to being on your feet for so long and running. This shoe just really accommodate that. So whether you wear it through the whole run, whether you wear it on your longest days or whether you change into this shoe late in the long race, this is really a go-to-shoe as fas as that concerned.

  • 70 / 100 | TriTwinsMom | Level 1 expert

    After wearing this Stinson ATR 5, I felt like I had clounds on my feet with the Clifton's. That's how dramatically is to Clifton 5. So, if you want something that's very dense, not a typical Hoka, Saucony feel but you still kinda rocker, then this is you shoe. Other than that, I'm sorry to say, I can't like this shoe.

  • 97 / 100 | JackRabbit | | Level 1 expert

    The Stinson ATR 5 will continue to give a nice balance of cushion and lightweight running for all your terrain adventures.

  • 70 / 100 | Running Shoes Guru | | Level 1 expert

    While these are not the fastest race shoes, they are reliable, durable, and inspire confidence over long efforts on most types of terrain.

  • First look | ffencino

  • First look | Road Runner Sports | | Level 4 expert

Become an expert

  • In this fifth iteration of the Hoka One One Stinson ATR, improvements in fit could be found all over. This update provides runners with an all-new level of comfort for any type of run—either long or short distances. The Stinson ATR 5 is perfect for neutral pronators who are looking for a technical shoe that could readily perform on various trail surfaces.
  • The upper of the Stinson ATR 5 features an updated toe box, which offers a more refined fit. Meanwhile, the rest of the upper delivers more lockdown as an overall. The structure of this shoe still includes the arch-lock wings in the midfoot for security, while other elements deliver breathability and durability.
  • The sole unit continues the usage of Hoka One One’s Late-Stage Meta-Rocker technology, which offers additional stability and encourages a smooth toe-off. A unique blend of compression-molded ethylene-vinyl acetate (CMEVA) foam maintains the midsole’s lightness. Then, a podular outsole design allows for easy traversing on uneven terrains.

The Hoka Stinson ATR 5 follows the sizing scheme of most running shoes; thus, runners should expect a perfect fit with their usual size preferences. Some might want to go for a half-size higher if they wear thick socks, or want more wiggle room in the toe area. The Hoka One One Stinson ATR 5 comes in medium width for both the men’s and women’s versions.

In terms of tread pattern and overall construction, the outsole of the Stinson ATR does not differ greatly from its predecessor. This shoe retains the 4-mm lugs made from sticky rubber, which works well in providing grip on various surfaces.

The structure of the outsole is built from a high-abrasion rubber with a full-ground pod design. It offers stability on uneven terrain and shock absorption when running on brutal trails.

The high-volume midsole of the Stinson ATR 5 supply the foot with maximum-level cushioning and comfort. Made from CMEVA, the midsole foam is lightweight despite the thick structure. The shoe’s low-drop construction helps in forefoot striking, which is further encouraged by the Late-Stage Meta-Rocker. Another low-drop trail running shoe, for comparison, is the Brooks Caldera 3.

The midsole employs Hoka One One’s proprietary Late-Stage Meta-Rocker technology, a design concept that promotes stable forefoot support and smooth transition phase. As opposed to its counterpart the Early-Stage Meta-Rocker, the Late-Stage variety forms the midsole with a geometry that places the transition zone in front.

Most of the design in the upper of the Stinson ATR 5 has been retained from the previous version, including the open-mesh material used to create the Speedframe technology of the shoe. With Speedframe, the upper boasts of a seamless construction that is durable yet soft enough to allow comfortable wear.

Another feature that makes it way back from the older Stinson ATR is the arch-lock wings design, found in the midfoot area of the upper. The arch-lock wings deliver the necessary support and security. They are connected to the shoe’s lacing system, which further strengthens the locked-down fit. This detail also prevents discomfort and injury that is usually caused by an unstable ride.

Like many other Hoka One One running shoes, the Stinson ATR 5 includes a heel pull-tab and a padded heel and collar. These elements work in giving extra convenience, protection, and comfort to make the run more enjoyable.

Comparison

Author
https://cdn.runrepeat.com/wp-content/uploads/jens-jakob-andersen.jpg
Jens Jakob Andersen

Jens Jakob is a fan of short distances with a 5K PR at 15:58 minutes. Based on 35 million race results, he's among the fastest 0.2% runners. Jens Jakob previously owned a running store, when he was also a competitive runner. His work is regularly featured in The New York Times, Washington Post, BBC and the likes as well as peer-reviewed journals. Finally, he has been a guest on +30 podcasts on running.

jens@runrepeat.com