How we review water hiking shoes
We’ve all been there: trying to find a perfect shoe and finding only a few of them listed on top-10 lists, without transparent reasoning, but highly backed with behind-the-screen promotions. That’s why we’ve created the CoreScore.
After we’ve gathered and read reviews from 13 hiking experts and 225 users, thanks to the CoreScore, we were able to rate water hiking shoes on a 0-100 scale and rank them: based on ratings, popularity, price, discounts, etc. You can even filter them to match your criteria!
Top pick See our full review and facts
The Merrell Choprock has got to be the most amphibious of them all.
After months of use and reviewing 100+ water hiking shoes, all we can say is that this bad boy can really hit it out of the park where slosh and shallow waters are involved. It is just THAT awesome!
One of the secrets to its stellar success as the best of the best is its in-built ports, which eject all sorts of fluids with every step, without fail! And did we mention that it dries quicker than you can say “no” to asparagus?
But seriously—this astonishing piece from Merrell we find to be relentless at keeping pace with your every stride. At no more than 380 grams per shoe (which is moderately light for its kind), the Choprock allowed us to breeze past puddles and traipse through streams without ever getting tired feet after the fact.
The Choprock doesn’t disappoint in the area of grip, either. The geniuses at Merrell’s shoe lab have done a fantastic job at creating a kind of outsole that, without a sliver of a doubt, simply sticks. We mounted on some wet logs, trampled over pebbles, and went up moist slopes (with some moss), and we didn’t slip—NOT. ONE. BIT.
Ok, at $120, the Choprock might be among the slightly expensive bunch, but you really get what you pay for investing in this remarkably amphibious gem (as cliché as that may sound).
Anyway, get the Choprock as fast as you can! We can say this boldly, simply because we became true believers after witnessing everything it has to offer.
Top pick See our full review and facts
Bonkers! Yes, Astral’s TR1 Junction made us go gaga with how it made us feel like ninjas, whether or not wetness was involved. Props to its astounding 300 grams of weight (per shoe), our dreams of slicing through mildly murky creeks and some 2-inch puddles came true!
Straight out of the gate, the TR1 Junction readily pampered our feet—not a single second was spent breaking in this amphibious bad boy.
Now hear this: We’ve tested over a hundred water hiking shoes, and only in the TR1 Junction did we ever feel right at home. Our toes weren’t squished at all; it was like the shoe was an open-toe sandal with its astonishingly spacious toe box.
But how does it perform on wet/slick surfaces, you ask? Well, the TR1 Junction was simply amazing on some mossy roots. We also didn’t slip during our low-level boulder-hopping in this shallow stream, so we’d say you’re in for a grippy ride wearing this kick.
In terms of shedding water, the Astral TR1 Junction is nothing to be sneezed at, either. While we rank the Merrell Choprock as the best in this regard, this featherweight hiker comes a very close second. We just wish it had more water-ejecting channels at the heel.
And before we forget—the TR1 Junction dries so fast. Some ten minutes after wading through this semi-flooded part of the trail, we noticed that the shoe’s upper got rid of the drench as if we used a blow-dryer on it!
Yup, the TR1 Junction is a lightweight beast in and around water. You probably should get it now!
See our full review and facts
If you thought you couldn’t get any more pampering in a pair of water hiking sandals, think again—the Merrell Hydro Moc will blow your socks off! (Not that wearing socks in sandals is cool or anything, mind you.)
Part of its immense level of comfort can be linked to the tongue-tying smoothness of its interior. It’s not lined, but the moment we slipped into it, all we could utter was almost a breathless “wow,” similar to how Owen Wilson says it.
Oh, but let’s not forget how it stunned in the performance category. Sticking to wet surfaces — think always-wet low-level boulders and mossy logs — is the Hydro Moc’s business, after all. Still, the most mesmerizing part? When we ventured into the drier parts of the trail, we felt like absolute lizard kings!
Underfoot, this some 400-gram-a-pair water hiker (wow, that’s light!) is so supportive that it would be criminal not to mention it here. We never lost footing in the entirety of our journey, which was across rocky terrain and root-filled tracks.
And before you make an assumption that all this awesomeness comes at a hefty price, don’t. We were equally stunned to discover that a pair of this aquatic marvel is just $50. How amazing is that!?
We’re just not too sure about its synthetic upper, though. While it screams longevity, we felt a bit hot inside it. Still, this super-comfy, light, and humbly priced Merrell hiker is, without a doubt, a god-send!
See our full review and facts
If there’s one water hiking shoe that gives you the most bang for your buck, it has got to be the All Out Blaze Sieve from Merrell. It shouldn’t come as a surprise, really, as its combination of features wrapped in a 100-dollar-ish package is not something you would want to pass up.
But for context, let’s talk about its comfort level. Almost from the get-go, the All Out Blaze Sieve was more than ready to pamper our feet. The leather upper has that plush lining, and the footbed, although textured for slippage prevention, spoiled our tootsies to the nines!
We also want to swivel the spotlight toward grip. We trampled over smooth, wet rocks (like oversized pebbles) and, we never lost our footing. We also made our way across this mossy part of the trail, and we didn’t slip.
Despite its lightness (it’s about 500 g a pair), we were positively shocked about how greatly it protected our feet. The trail we tested this on was rocky and gnarly roots didn’t make the negotiations simple, but the All Out Blaze Sieve was a tank through and through!
We are also quite confident that this offering will last long. Its construction is just satisfyingly solid—it protected our feet against abrasive roots and rocks, and it came out without noticeable scratches.
7 features to look for in water hiking shoes
Water hiking demands a certain shoe feature set because of the specific hiking conditions. Otherwise, people would just pun on their Crocs and set out for an amphibian adventure.
To be on the safe, comfortable, and responsible side, it’s recommended to look for this feature set in water hiking shoes:
- Comfort - Always #1 when buying new footwear. This is important in order to avoid discomfort and injuries, especially if you plan to build up the mileage in these shoes.
- Traction - An excellent grip is a must when it comes to slippery surfaces.
- Water drainage - While some might think that water hiking shoes should be waterproof, it’s just the opposite. They need to allow the water to get back to where it came from. This means that shoes usually have drainage holes or large mesh areas: they allow the water to leave the shoe and prevent the dirt and rocks from getting in the shoe.
- Quick-drying - It’s important that, once the water leaves the shoe, your feet and shoes start drying out as soon as possible. Inner sole and upper materials are responsible for this: they are usually made of quick-drying synthetic materials. This feature prevents frostbites when water hiking through really cold waters.
- Toe cap - These shoes should keep your toes safe from debris and rocks. Toe caps come in different shapes and sizes and are in charge of this.
- Lightweight - So you move with ease, both when dry and wet.
- Secure fit - Your feet should not slide around in the shoe.
Of course, if you have any specific requirements (e.g. stability features, cushioning) regarding your foot condition, don’t put them on the side. We’ve covered these basics in the chapter below.
How to buy the right water hiking shoe
If this is your first hiking shoe, there are certain things that need your attention so that the hiking shoe is your perfect fit. Also, you might want to learn more about hiking shoes: read our guide for hiking shoes.
1. Duration of your hiking trip
- Water hiking shoes aren’t made for long multi-day hiking trips with heavy backpacks and demanding terrain.
- You can use them on your short hikes - whether it’s a 200meter creek crossing or canyon-exploring that lasts a whole day.
- Keep in mind that, the longer the water hike, the better support you need. This means you should look for more stability features and cushioning.
2. Weight of your backpack
- The same rule applies for the duration of your hiking trip. We bring heavier backpacks on longer hikes. Water hiking shoes aren’t meant to support you in these adventures completely, only up to a degree. That’s why, if possible, change your hiking shoes, use the regular ones while you’re on (dry) land.
- If you know you’ll be carrying a heavier backpack, look for stability features and cushioning.
3. Your arch type
- Depending on your arch type, your feet might need different stability features.
- High arches usually ask for neutral shoes, medium arches ask for neutral or stability shoes and low arches (flat feet) ask for motion control shoes. We’ve covered this in-depth in the next chapter.
4. How the shoe fits
To make sure you choose the good-fitting shoe, follow these steps:
- Go shopping in the afternoon. Your feet are swollen then, which happens regularly on hikes
- Try the shoe on and check for pressure points. The shoe should feel snug, but not restricting.
- Use the ramp and walk up and down. Crossing water is rarely monotonous. Usually, the terrain is dynamic with a lot of obstacles, ups, and downs. Your heel should not rise more than a ¼ of an inch. Your toes should not hit the front of the shoe when going downhill.
Arch type and stability features
The type of your arch matters because it offers guidelines for choosing the adequate shoe type. Whether it’s a neutral, stability, or motion control shoe - they all offer different stability features that your feet need when hiking.
Shoe wear test
Things you can do: look at your used hiking shoes and compare how the outsoles have been worn with the “Shoe wear” section below.
If you’re overpronating, you can look for overpronation hiking shoes. If you’re a neutral pronator or a supinator, browse through the neutral hiking shoes database.
There is also another way to discover your arch type and it’s called a wet test.
You should: wet the sole of your foot (ideally both of them, one at a time), then stand on a piece of paper while allowing the moisture from your feet to sink into the paper, and step off.
Look at the shape of your footprint and compare it to the ones shown below.
If you’re not confident about this test or feel your feet need more attention, consult a podiatrist. They implement a holistic approach by looking at your barefoot movement, pronation, tibia rotation, and heel deviation.
Comfort and cushioning features
What does “look for cushioning” actually mean?
- Water hiking shoes are usually lacking cushioning features or at least a great amount of cushioning. The general advice is to look for more cushioning (again, yes) if the water hike is longer and planned for demanding and dynamic terrain.
- Short water hikes, light backpacks, and soft or monotonous surfaces can be done in water hiking shoes that are flatter and offer less cushioning.
- While with running shoes you have so many options - where padding (extra cushioning) is placed, how much of it, how bouncy it is, what’s the energy return,... - with hiking shoes it’s simpler.
Expert advice for water hiking shoes
- If you know you’ll be crossing waters with a lot of tiny rocks or debris, look for water hiking shoes without drainage holes. If the holes are placed on the upper part of your shoes, they might let unwanted materials into your shoes. You don’t want to waste time getting the debris out of your shoes or getting blisters because of them.
- As soon as you’re done with crossing waters or with your hike, take your shoes off. Clean them and let them dry at an airy or sunny spot. If your shoes have removable insoles, the shoes will dry even quicker if the insoles are taken out.
- In most cases, you can clean your water hiking shoes with hot water and baking soda. But, always check for brand-recommended advice - cleaning process, special detergents, etc.
- When hiking on mixed terrain, it’s better to take your water hiking shoes with you and use them only when crossing water. That’s why it’s important for them to be lightweight, so you can hang them on your backpack and keep pushing further, without feeling them wearing you down.
- Dry bags or dry sacks prove to be of great value when crossing water! Keep your stuff safe from water (splashing, waves, rain) and pack everything in them.
Weight and price of water hiking shoes
When compared to the other types of hiking shoes, water hiking shoes are the cheapest and lightest.
Keep in mind that these prices are the manufacturer’s suggested retail prices, meaning that’s how much the shoe costs once it hits the market. We always encourage people to find a great deal.
Tips for finding hiking shoes at cheap prices
Here are some tips to help you land a good deal.
- Browse online stores. Usually, they allow for shoes to be filtered by price or discount.
- Browse online shoe databases. Much more comprehensive than regular online stores. RunRepeat database is updated on a daily basis and offers to sort by discount (from less than 30% to more than 70%).
- Use “price drop” email alerts. Some shoes are worth waiting for, so why not get an email once their price drops.
- Pay attention to older models, they tend to be discounted more often than new models. Especially if you’re offline shopping, smaller shops might have those models on sale.
- Exercise caution if buying on Black Friday. Turns out sneakers are cheaper on 66% of days throughout the year than they are on Black Friday. Worth keeping in mind when buying hiking shoes too.