Verdict from 7.1 hours of research from the internet

9 reasons to buy

  • A lot of customers have shared that the Frye Melanie Slip On is a comfortable sneaker.
  • This fashion sneaker possesses class and beauty, according to plenty of reviewers. 
  • Many users have praised the shoe’s quality workmanship.  
  • Like other Frye shoes, this kick has a versatile design that can work well with shorts, jeggings, pants, and other casual outfits, as per several wearers. 
  • Some reviewers appreciate that the Frye Melanie Slip On is available in a variety of beautiful colorways. 
  • One happily shares that the leather upper is easy to clean. 
  • Because of the shoe’s classy and fashionable design, several customers are happy to share that they receive compliments whenever they wear this footwear.
  • These flats offer a reliable grip, as one has noted. 
  • A tester notices that this sneaker maintains the shape of the foot 

3 reasons not to buy

  • Several users complain about the fit of the Frye Melanie Slip On being narrow. 
  • It does not provide any arch support, according to a couple of purchasers.
  • A few buyers have mentioned that it is a little pricey. 

Bottom line

For those who seek a straightforward shoe with a classy vibe, the Frye Melanie Slip On is worth a try. This style does not compromise the comfort and quality workmanship that it also provides. Also, it possesses the versatility to quickly match a variety of outfits for different occasions. 

Just one thing to note by future buyers, the construction of the shoe has been reported to fit a bit narrow. Nevertheless, this chic shoe is loved by many for its durability, style, and comfort.

User reviews:

The Frye Melanie Slip On is available in women’s sizing. Depending on the colorway, it has an upper crafted from nubuck, suede, or leather material that gives decent foot breathability. Without the complicated lacing system, it allows the foot to quickly slide in and out from it. 

This fashion sneaker has a low-top profile that allows the ankle to move without any restriction. It has a sufficient cushioned leather insole that gives all-day comfort. Also, the lining is made of leather material that delivers an excellent next-to-skin feel. 

This model features a molded footbed covered with leather material, providing underfoot comfort and cushioning. It also has a cushioned collar that adds support and comfort. Equipped with the side goring, it provides a snug and flexible fit.

The Frye Melanie Slip On is available in a variety of colorways. Depending on the color variations, the upper is made of nubuck, antique vintage or metallic leather material that gives a sophisticated look. This low-top sneaker with a slip-on style can perfectly match a variety of casual and smart casual outfits. 

Among the suggested ways to style the shoes are:

  • Ladies can opt for a navy polka dot wrap dress and match it with this leather slip-on for a perfect casual getup.
  • A cognac or black pair of Frye Melanie Slip-On can work well with a black and white blazer and tapered plaid pants, providing a good combination of comfort and fashionable look.

A paradigm of sophistication and comfort, the Frye Melanie Slip On is a testimony that simplicity can be a great asset. It features a beautiful upper that is made from premium material, delivering style and durability. Also, the shoe’s upper gives not only a luxurious look but an uncompromising comfort.  

In 1863, John A. Frye established his first Frye shop on Elm Street, Marlboro, Massachusetts. In the 1890s, the city of Marlboro manufactured shoes more than other cities in the United States. Back in the 1960s, Frye made custom cleats for celebrities like Barbara Streisand, Bette Midler, Bing Crosby, Jerry Lewis, Jackie Kennedy, Candie Bergen, Carole King, President Richard Nixon, and Walt Frazier. 

For decades, the brand’s iconic cleats embodied social movements, defined eras, outlasted trends, and defied time. Frye was able to capture the essence of the timeless American style. 

Jimlar from the Kravetz group, a shoe company that manufactured Coach footwear under license, acquired the Frye company in 1998. In 2010, Li & Fung company acquired Jimlar and then eventually spun off its brand management as Global Brands Group in the year 2014. 

  A promising sneaker from Frye

Currently, aside from cleats, the brand manufactures not only casual cleats but also sneakers that offer casual comfort and elegance. The Frye Melanie Slip On is among the promising sneakers that the brand offers today. 

This low-top shoe with a slip-on style has a classy and fashionable silhouette perfect for women on-the-go. With different color variations to choose from, this chic sneaker possesses versatility that can quickly complement a variety of outfits. Ladies can choose to dress up or down with this shoe. 

Crafted with a premium upper, the Frye Melanie Slip On offers style and comfort. Its footbed is sufficiently padded. This shoe also features scuffing on the toe bumpers, rubber heel and outsole for a well-worn appearance. Also, the rubber outsole has the signature tread that gives excellent traction.

  • The Frye Melanie Slip On has a heel height that measures 0.75 inches.
  • It has an elastic gore trim that provides a flexible fit. 
  • The shoe weighs 226.796 grams. 
  • It is available in colorways like aqua, cognac, grey, blue antique soft vintage, camel buffed nubuck, coral nubuck, sea blue, lilac, moonlight, gold/metallic leather, sunrise, pewter metallic leather, taupe, blush, and gold metallic suede. 
Danny McLoughlin
Danny McLoughlin

Danny McLoughlin is a researcher for RunRepeat covering football, sneakers and running. After graduating with a degree in computer science from The University of Strathclyde, Danny makes sure never to miss a game of his beloved Glasgow Rangers or the Scotland national football team. He has been featured in prestigious publications such as The Washington Post, The Irish Times, Footwear News and the like.