Summary

We spent 7.6 hours reading reviews from experts and users. In summary, this is what approachers think:

5 reasons to buy

  • Some of those who have bought the Scarpa Mescalito GTX approach shoe are deeply impressed with its fantastic level of comfort.
  • Its grip performance is extraordinary, according to a small number of reviewers.
  • This remarkable approach shoe has superb waterproofing, say a few of those who have tested it.
  • Based on a report, the Mescalito GTX is incredibly durable.
  • Someone who has hiked in this astonishing Scarpa approach shoe says that it breathes well.

2 reasons not to buy

  • The Scarpa Mescalito GTX might be a bit of a tough sell for some with its slightly expensive price tag.
  • A disappointed owner finds the shoe’s overall fit not very accommodating of thick socks.

Bottom line

It is not that hard to fall in love with the Mescalito GTX from Scarpa. Indeed, the product in question stuns with its excellent comfiness, surface traction, and water protection. The shoe is also quite long-wearing—a quality many consider a great plus in approach footwear.

That said, this hiker might not be as budget-friendly as some might expect. Nevertheless, the Scarpa Mescalito GTX has more than enough positives to embolden those who would give it a shot.

Facts

Rankings

A top 5% best approach-shoe
Top 10% most popular approach-shoes

Reviews from around the internet

Expert reviews:

User reviews:

Amazon, SportsShoes and 22 other shops don't have user reviews

-The Scarpa Mescalito GTX, the sibling of the non-waterproof Mescalito, is a shoe designed for technical approach endeavors. Its designers imbued it with a Gore-Tex membrane to make it watertight.

-This shoe is built with abrasion protection in mind—it has a stitched-on leather upper with 360-degree randing. It is also engineered to make strides feel more natural with its rockered sole unit.

-It comes with two Scarpa technologies: Activ Impact and Activ Fit. The former provides enhanced shock absorption, while the latter gives the shoe improved durability without sacrificing comfort, style, and performance.

Scarpa’s Mescalito GTX is a low-top approach shoe for men and women. In it, users can get a personalized lockdown using the hiker’s lace-up closure. The engineers over at Scarpa gave this fit management system an ankle-to-toe construction, which provides owners with more configuration options.

The Mescalito GTX promises to keep the wearer as surefooted as possible on virtually all sorts of backcountry surfaces with its Vibram Megagrip outsole. It is designed to provide a level of stickiness that works no matter if the terrain is wet or dry. It is also imbued with Vibram’s Dynamis Litebase (LB) technology, making it a lightweight component—about 50% lighter than most.

This grippy layer has treaded lugs scattered all around it, rendering it capable of latching on to loose soil and similar surfaces. It also has a climbing zone, which delivers added grip over smooth rock.

This approach-focused hiker is armed with a segmented midsole made of EVA (ethylene-vinyl acetate). It grants adequate cushioning and footing balance at the same time, thanks to its dual-density construction. Bridging the gap between the midsole’s heel and forefoot sections is a TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) insert. The presence of this additional sole component translates to enhanced stability. What elevates the midsole’s provision of comfort, on the other hand, is the Mescalito GTX’s default footbed.

The Scarpa Mescalito GTX has a water-resistant suede leather upper. Slipping in and out of it is a relatively quick affair, thanks to the synthetic loop stitched to its heel. It comes with a padded tongue and a plush collar made of stretch fabric for extra in-shoe comfort. The “GTX” in its name refers to Gore-Tex—the company behind the shoe’s Extended Comfort liner. This particular liner makes the hiker sufficiently breathable on the inside while adequately waterproof on the outside. To protect the shoe from scrapes, cuts, and scratches, Scarpa designers reinforced its lower section with a full-on rand made of lightweight PU (polyurethane). They also furnished the upper’s toe box with heavy-duty rubber for protection against bumpy hazards.

Rounding out all things upper in the Mescalito GTX is the shoe’s Extended Lacing lockdown system. It is made up of regular eyelets and a synthetic lace

The Mescalito GTX is one of the best approach shoes Scarpa has ever produced. As such, it has enough popularity for people to pit it against other kicks under the approach category. In this head-to-head, the featured hiker finds a rival in the Arc’teryx Acrux SL GTX. The areas in which they differ will be discussed in the following:

Upper. The Scarpa Mescalito GTX, as previously mentioned (see Upper section above), sports a suede leather upper. The one in the Arc’teryx Acrux SL GTX, on the other hand, is made of nylon with polyurethane coating. Between the two approach shoes, only the Mescalito GTX has a protective rand around its lower perimeter.

Price tag. On this front, approach fans might find the Mescalito GTX the more enticing purchase. Yes, the featured shoe is cheaper than the Acrux SL GTX by approximately 20 US dollars.

Weight. In this round, the Arc’teryx Acrux SL GTX takes home the crown. Indeed, it is about 200 g lighter than the Scarpa Mescalito GTX.

Lacing system. While both approach shoes in this comparison have a traditional lace-up closure, only the one in the Mescalito GTX has a to-toe construction.

On and off. Adventurers might find the Arc’teryx Acrux SL GTX the better product in this regard. This is because the shoe in question has two pull loops, with the second one stitched to its tongue. In comparison, the Mescalito GTX only has one.

Author
Jens