Verdict from 12 experts and 100+ user reviews

7 reasons to buy

  • The Five Ten Guide Tennie approach shoes please a majority of wearers with its comfort.
  • Several owners have commented that they are stoked with its supportive midsole that comes handy when pounding hard trails and carrying moderate loads.
  • The excellent smearing ability of this comfy Five Ten approach shoe delights a considerable number of users.
  • Based on a couple of expert reviews, the Guide Tennie’s forefoot flexibility is awesome.
  • Some hikers testify to the durability of the toe rubber as it is able to withstand rough rock edges.
  • The thick padding around the ankle of this 5.10 approach shoe is appreciated by a small group of testers.
  • Most buyers state that they love the cool look of the Guide Tennie.

3 reasons not to buy

  • A few testers dislike the somewhat blister-inducing break-in period of the Guide Tennie from 5.10.
  • Less than a handful of critics mention that the dotty pattern on the sole does not excel on wet terrain.
  • An owner is not impressed with its walking performance over more level terrain.

Bottom line

The Guide Tennie is a highly recommendable approach shoe, thanks to its amazing supply of comfort and support. It is also something that people can appreciate in the areas of mobility and style. And this is without mention of the shoe's remarkably tough build yet.

However, despite these satisfying features, a couple of criticisms still hound it. With all that said, the Guide Tennie from Five Ten seems quite capable of providing a balance between hiking performance and low-grade climbing prowess.

Good to know

-The redesigned Five Ten Guide Tennie offers an all-around kind of performance, thanks to its capabilities on both hikes and easy climbs. It kept the same amount of toe rubber for durability and friction.

-This revamped version includes updates in the heel counter for greater stability and to its to-the-toe lacing for a more precise fit. The 5.10 logo has also been replaced. The compression-molded midsole and Stealth rubber outsole are features inherited from its predecessor.

The Five Ten Guide Tennie comes in men and women’s variants. It has a low-clearance cuff height. The women's variant has a lower volume to grant a female-specific fit.

The leather upper of the shoe has a minimal level of stretch. Furthermore, its to-the-toe lacing system facilitates a highly customized fit.

This 5.10 approach shoe carries a Stealth C4 rubber outsole. This proprietary component is designed to provide adequate grip performance on virtually all types of terrain. Its Dotty tread pattern (or its set of circular lugs) prevents the accumulation of sticky dirt and debris, maintaining traction even on muddy surfaces.

The hand-ground beveled toe section yields precise edging, especially on small footholds. The rubber patch at the toe (a.k.a. the shoe's climbing zone) also grants a certain degree of edging and smearing friction. 

Five Ten’s Guide Tennie is furnished with a compression-molded midsole. It is made of EVA or ethylene-vinyl acetate, a material known widely for high resilience and rebound. The presence of this cushy component translates to sufficient comfort and stability, particularly on long hikes and demanding approaches. Moreover, it grants users adequate support, particularly during scrambling.

The genius minds behind this 5.10 pair topped its midsole with a comfy footbed. It ups the hiker's supportivemess, especially around the arch. This removable element has a textured surface to prevent underfoot slippage. 

The low-top upper of the Five Ten Guide Tennie is made with a combination of synthetic fabric and suede leather. Aside from protecting the foot against outdoor obstacles, this sturdy shell also yields ample breathability and a degree of water-resistance. Its interior is lined with mesh to enhance comfort, while its grippy rubber rand at the forefoot heightens durability.

The lace-to-toe closure system of this Five Ten shoe employs a flat lace that passes through nine pairs of eyelets. This component assists in fit management. When configured the right way, users may climb in it with enough support and footing assurance. On the other hand, loosening it grants hiking comfort. 

The heel counter helps stabilize the foot inside the shoe. Additionally, the heel area has a pull tab that expedites on and off. It can also be used by climbers to clip their shoes to their pack or harness while taking on single- or multi-pitch climbs.

The Guide Tennie is among Five Ten's most popular approach kicks. With that, many users and critics like to compare it with some of the most in-demand approach-centric shoes from other brands. In this case, the featured 5.10 piece is pitted against the La Sportiva TX4. The following are aspects that set the two kicks apart.

Pricing. Both approach shoes in this area have seen some changes over the years, for better or worse. That said, between the two, the Guide Tennie is the more appealing product, as it is about $20 more affordable than the TX4.

Weight. On this front, the La Sportiva TX4 edges out the featured shoe by a hair. Yes, it is lighter than the Guide Tennie by approximately 10 grams.

Randing. The Five Ten Guide Tennie has a partial rubber rand at the forefoot. Its rival, on the other hand, has a full-on rand, covering practically the upper's entire lower perimeter.


How Five Ten Guide Tennie ranks compared to all other shoes
Top 45% approach shoes
All approach shoes
Bottom 33% Five Ten approach shoes
All Five Ten approach shoes
Top 46% water resistant approach shoes
All water resistant approach shoes


The current trend of Five Ten Guide Tennie.
Compare to another shoe: