Summary

We spent 8.4 hours reading reviews from experts and users. In summary, this is what cyclers think:

6 reasons to buy

  • The Giro Gauge’s soles are stiff yet flexible enough for walking comfort, according to most of the reviewers’ opinions.
  • A significant number of wearers find this mountain bike shoe to be comfortable.
  • Walking is less annoying and more convenient thanks to the shoe’s recessed cleats. This eliminates the click-clack sound of the cleats hitting the floor.
  • This cycling footgear is durable, say several users.
  • The Giro Gauge looks aesthetically appealing, admits a number of purchasers.
  • Some wearers claim that it has excellent quality in both construction and materials.

2 reasons not to buy

  • A few nitpicking comments say that the shoe is quite heavy for their liking.
  • A commuter cyclist says that the shoe could’ve been better if it featured a bit of weatherproofing.

Bottom line

The Giro Gauge is an MTB shoe that’s reported to deliver the same feel as that of a trail running shoe. It offers a mix of on and off-bike comfort, power transfer, and grip. With its overall construction and aesthetic, folks have been using it for commuting or spinning (indoor cycling).

If you’re commuting, make sure that you’re up-to-date with the weather so you can go to work and back with dry feet.

Tip: see the best cycling shoes.

Facts

Reviews from around the internet

User reviews:

SportsShoes, Zappos and 20 other shops don't have user reviews

The Gauge by Giro is an athletic-inspired mountain bike shoe that’s both comfortable and adequately equipped for sessions on trails and roads. This shoe possesses the signature rugged soles of off-bike shoes and the athletic looks of running shoes.

With lugged rubber outsoles for grip and stout injected nylon inner shanks to aid in power transfer, sessions on the rugged trails are enjoyable. Cycling-specific features such as SPD-pedal compatibility, the rider is provided with a direct connection to his bike.

Grip and power transfer. With the Giro Gauge’s injected nylon plate inserted in the outsoles, efficient power transfer is delivered. While a full-length rubber outsole with aggressive lugs yields high-traction for grip and stability on smooth surfaces.

The Giro Gauge works with 2-bolt pedals and cleat systems such as Shimano XTR M9020 Trail SPD, Nukeproof Horizon CS CrMo, and Shimano XT M8000 XC Race Pedals. 

Moreover, the shoe comes with a cover for the cleat area so the wearers can use it as a flat MTB shoe. If you choose to use it as a flat shoe, try the following pedals: Crank Brothers 5050 xx, Twenty6 Predator, and Race Face Chester.

Durable and lightweight. This pair’s upper is crafted from Thermo-bonded TPU and mesh. The TPU offers durability and protection, while the mesh allows excellent airflow. Overall, this construction equates to a lightweight build.

Protection. Equipped with rock print reinforced toe overlay and synthetic heel overlay, abrasions and impacts are deflected.

Time-tested lockdown. The Giro Gauge employs the classic lace-up closure. It offers unrivaled fit and is the lightest retention system in the market. A lace tuck is provided to keep the laces from getting caught in the bike’s crankset.

This footwear employs die-cut EVA footbeds with medium arch supports. They are removable so you can exchange it for another insole if needed.

An older version of the Giro Gauge features a Ratchet and Velcro strap combination for its closure system.